“Are we doing what is best for our students, or are we doing what is most convenient for us?”
I feel like many of us have been getting to comfortable in the way we teach. There are many teachers that are "old school" and feel that all these changes required by our lawmakers and administrators are pure nonsense. I was overhearing a conversation between a first year teacher and a seasoned teacher and as the seasoned teacher complained about all the new things we had to do she asked the new teacher what was her take on all this. The new teacher replied, "Well, this is all I know, so for me it is what I have to do and probably I don't see it as any different than how you saw what you were required to do when you first started." Great answer!
I have only been teaching for 7 years, but when I finally was starting to get comfortable in what I was doing, our lawmakers decided that it was time for change. Wow! It has been very overwhelming for a lot of us! We are required to do so much more than what we used to. Not that we weren't working hard aready! A lot of teachers are wondering how all these new teacher evaluations required by Florida schools are really helping our students.
I always felt that I was going above and beyond with my students by trying to do activities that challenged them and made them think critically. Recently, Orange County Public Schools have added STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) projects to our curriculum. These are great for students and they help them become better problem solvers and critical thinkers. I feel like these projects are only a small step in the right direction, because overall we have a long way to go. As far as technology goes, the teachers at my school feel that we are blessed compared to other schools. However, after looking at some of the examples in the videos and on the websites provided by our professor I feel like we are far behind! Just check out this video: Summit on 21st Century Skills: Kansas Technology Rich Classroom Project and you will see what I am talking about!
I really liked the example I read in one of the comments to the same question stated above...it talked about teachers being in four quadrants: highly effective, very convenient; highly effective, not convenient; convenient, but not effective; and not convenient, not effective. I think most of us fall under the "highly effective, not convenient" category. We want our students to succeed, we do whatever we can to achieve this, we overwork ourselves, but we get the job done. Our students are making adequate progress and our school has an "A" grade. At least that is true for the majority of the teachers at my school. However, we are tired, feel underappreciated, and underpaid for all we do.
Hopefully, in the near future we can find a balance where everyone is happy, lawmakers, administrators, teachers, parents, and students. After all, I think our goal is the same for all of us!
Larissa,
ReplyDeleteGreat blog! I completely agree that most teachers do feel unappreciated and underpaid! It is an awful feeling for all we do. Not only are we the teacher but we are so much more these students now a day. I can say though when you do get that "thank you note" from a parent or that "I get it look" from a student, it is totally worth it!
I do disagree that most teachers fall into the "highly effective, not convenient" category. I think most teachers want to say or think they do, but they don't. I think most fall into the middle somewhere. My daughter had a kindergarten teacher 4 years ago that told us at open house she has to "get through this year before she could retire!!!!" She was awful, and the sad part...she is still teaching because she needs the money. I feel so sad for students of teachers like that!
All in all I think your blog had great facts and drew wonderful examples. I really do feel like most teachers can say that they fall somewhere in those 4 categories!
Kristen Gulliford Turner
Kristen,
DeleteI am very excited to get my first comment! I agree with you, whenever you experience the rewards of teaching it makes it all worth it! I can see what you are saying about the majority of teachers not being in the "highly effective, not convenient" category. I guess in my little sheltered world that I live in, it is mostly like that. I have taught at two schools and for the most part everyone is like that. However, there are a couple like the teacher you mentioned. But, you are right, overall there are more out there than we'd like them to be. :o( It is sad to hear about teachers like the one your daughter had in kindergarten. I can imagine how you felt when you heard that during open house. It must have been so disheartening!
Thanks again for your post!
Larisa
Hi Larissa,
ReplyDeleteI have been researching the STEM program recently because I was asked to teach both math and science at my school. While trying to order new curriculum to meet state standards, and make packets and busy work minimal, I find it hard to not get consumed with making a great course for my students. But then I have little time WITH my students. My time at work is limited, and it is difficult to weigh which is more pertinent: making cool interactive lessons which may be obsolete in a year, or spending quality instruction time with students. And on top of that, the news of the upcoming changes in teacher evaluations which leaves little to desire for star teachers in under performing school districts is disheartening. http://www.marzanoevaluation.com/fldoe/
sapient sojourn